{
 "generated": "2026-11-01",
 "node": {
  "id": "inst:nyt-ziff-davis-v-openai-microsoft",
  "type": "Instrument",
  "name": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入",
  "slug": "nyt-ziff-davis-v-openai-microsoft",
  "kind": "case",
  "kind_zh": "案件 / 判例",
  "date": "2023-12",
  "summary": "案件2023年12月提起，SDNY并案审理；2025年4月一审驳回大部分动议失败。司法部2026-09-02提交“利益声明”，主张训练新闻内容属合理使用，称向出版商付费授权会催生“AI寡头垄断”；NYT发言人公开反驳。",
  "evidence": [
   {
    "kind": "own",
    "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj",
    "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」的卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」：NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软"
   }
  ],
  "entry": "agent",
  "by": "landscape-facts",
  "at": "2026-11-01T11:19:35Z",
  "landscape": [
   {
    "map": "ai-governance",
    "map_title": "AI 治理与问责",
    "card": "player-nyt-openai-doj",
    "title": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入",
    "layer": "版权与 训练数据诉讼",
    "layer_id": "layer:ai-governance--3",
    "role": "primary"
   }
  ],
  "landscape_maps": [
   "ai-governance"
  ],
  "landscape_n": 1,
  "degree": 0
 },
 "page": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/graph/e/inst/nyt-ziff-davis-v-openai-microsoft/",
 "out": [
  {
   "type": "involves",
   "sentence": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入涉及纽约时报",
   "direction": "out",
   "id": "org:new-york-times",
   "name": "纽约时报（The New York Times）",
   "role": "plaintiff",
   "status": "agent",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "kind": "own",
     "label": "本站页面",
     "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」的卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」：NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软",
     "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "type": "involves",
   "sentence": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入涉及Ziff Davis",
   "direction": "out",
   "id": "org:ziff-davis",
   "name": "Ziff Davis",
   "role": "plaintiff",
   "status": "agent",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "kind": "own",
     "label": "本站页面",
     "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」的卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」：NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软",
     "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "type": "involves",
   "sentence": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入涉及OpenAI",
   "direction": "out",
   "id": "org:openai",
   "name": "OpenAI",
   "role": "defendant",
   "status": "agent",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "kind": "own",
     "label": "本站页面",
     "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」的卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」：NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软",
     "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "type": "involves",
   "sentence": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入涉及Microsoft",
   "direction": "out",
   "id": "org:microsoft",
   "name": "Microsoft",
   "role": "defendant",
   "status": "agent",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "kind": "own",
     "label": "本站页面",
     "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」的卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」：NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软",
     "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "type": "involves",
   "sentence": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入涉及美国司法部",
   "direction": "out",
   "id": "org:us-doj",
   "name": "美国司法部（DOJ）",
   "role": "participant",
   "note": "2026-09-02提交“利益声明”，主张训练新闻内容属合理使用，站在AI公司一边；助理司法部长Stanley Woodward Jr.称之为“历史性”",
   "status": "agent",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "kind": "own",
     "label": "本站页面",
     "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」的卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」：司法部2026-09-02提交\"利益声明\"",
     "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "type": "involves",
   "sentence": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入涉及美国纽约南区联邦地区法院",
   "direction": "out",
   "id": "org:us-sdny",
   "name": "美国纽约南区联邦地区法院（SDNY）",
   "role": "adjudicator",
   "note": "审理法院",
   "status": "agent",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "kind": "own",
     "label": "本站页面",
     "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」的卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」：SDNY并案审理",
     "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj"
    }
   ]
  },
  {
   "type": "placed_in",
   "sentence": "NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入出现在 Landscape 的「版权与训练数据诉讼」",
   "direction": "out",
   "id": "layer:ai-governance--3",
   "name": "版权与训练数据诉讼",
   "reported": false,
   "status": "derived",
   "evidence": [
    {
     "kind": "own",
     "label": "本站页面",
     "text": "Landscape「AI 治理与问责」第 03 层「版权与训练数据诉讼」：卡片「NYT/Ziff Davis 诉 OpenAI & 微软 + 司法部介入」",
     "url": "https://xiaopingfeng.com/landscape/ai-governance/#player-nyt-openai-doj"
    }
   ]
  }
 ],
 "in": []
}